Fertilizer granule strength insufficient?
First check three parameters: granulation moisture content, drying endpoint, and cooling temperature. When fertilizer granules lack strength, operators often immediately assume “the formula is wrong” or “too little binder.” However, on most production lines, the real variables lie in three process parameters: granulation moisture content, drying endpoint moisture content, and cooling endpoint temperature. Any deviation from the optimal range will significantly reduce compressive strength, and these three are precisely the indicators most easily overlooked during routine inspections.
I. Strength-Moisture-Temperature Three-Step Inspection Process
Granulation moisture content determines the initial density of the granules. The optimal moisture content for disc granulation is typically 28%–32%, with a suitable range of 25%–35% for organic fertilizer disc granulation: below 25%, the granules are loose and brittle; above 35%, the granules are too soft and prone to deformation after discharge. Insufficient moisture leads to discontinuous liquid bridges between particles, resulting in a loose mass of powder inside the granules. Excessive moisture, while allowing the granules to sphericalize, fills internal pores with water, leaving numerous voids after drying, thus reducing strength. The criterion for judging strength is that the granules should clump together when squeezed in the hand, with no water visible between the fingers, rather than relying on a rough estimate by feel.
The moisture content at the drying endpoint determines whether crystal bridges can fully form. The strength of rotary drum steam granulation primarily comes not from water binding, but from the crystal bridges formed by the partial dissolution and recrystallization of salts such as urea and monoammonium phosphate under humid heat. The moisture content before drying is typically 5%–6%, and after drying, it needs to be reduced to below 1% for the crystal bridges to fully solidify. Insufficient drying results in insufficient recrystallization of salts, leaving the granules internally “soft and wet”; excessive drying causes the granules to become brittle and break easily during cooling and transport.
The final cooling temperature determines whether the granules can maintain their strength. The outlet temperature of the cooler must be reduced to below 40℃, and the material temperature should ideally be below ambient temperature +5℃ before packaging. High-temperature packaged granules continue to dissipate heat inside the bag, causing internal moisture to migrate outwards and reform surface moisture at the granule contact points. This weakens strength and induces clumping. Many cases of granules “passing factory inspection but crumbling easily upon arrival at the customer’s hands” stem from the failure to maintain the final cooling temperature.
II. Relationship between Binder Type and Strength
Choosing the wrong binder or using too much cannot be compensated for by even the best triple-check process. Bentonite is low in cost, typically added at 3%-5%, but it is essentially an inert mineral; the more added, the more the effective nutrients are diluted. Adding 1%-3% lignin sulfonate can significantly improve pellet strength. At the same 2% dosage, sodium lignin sulfonate produces green pellets with a compressive strength (17.5 N/pellet) higher than bentonite (14.2 N/pellet). However, lignin sulfonate is more expensive and requires pH control between 6.5 and 7.5 to prevent microbial activity. A pragmatic choice is a composite binder: 2% bentonite and 1% lignin sulfonate, balancing cost and strength, rather than relying solely on one type.
III. Matching Particle Density with Extrusion/Rolling Processes
Particle strength is essentially a function of density, which is determined by the process route. Roller extrusion is a dry, room-temperature molding process with direct high-pressure compaction, resulting in high particle density and good initial strength, but the shape is often oblate or pillow-shaped, lacking roundness. Disc and drum extrusion are wet rolling processes, producing rounded particles, but density depends on rolling time and moisture control, resulting in relatively weaker particle strength, requiring compensation through return material ratio, residence time, and staged drying. Using disc processes to pursue roller-level strength, or using roller processes to pursue the appearance of discs, represents a mismatch between the process route and product objectives. First, clarify whether the market prioritizes “strength” or “appearance,” then match the process parameters to this route; only then will triple inspection be meaningful.
IV. Applying the Three-Step Check Across Organic Fertilizer Lines and Equipment
The three-step check should be implemented at the level of the whole organic fertilizer production line, not as an isolated laboratory test. On a chicken manure organic fertilizer production line, high viscosity and moisture variation make granulation moisture and drying endpoint especially sensitive; the organic fertilizer fermentation process determines fiber degradation and incoming moisture, which in turn affect granule density and strength. On a disc granulation production line, the 25%–35% moisture window and return material ratio should be checked together with cooling temperature before packaging. When selecting from an organic fertilizer granulator series, the machine type should be matched to the fermentation output and target strength: disc granulation favors rounded appearance, while extrusion routes favor density and initial strength. In any organic fertilizer production line, the practical rule is to link fermentation maturity, granulation moisture, drying endpoint, cooling temperature, and the chosen granulator model into one operating window. This is how the three-parameter check becomes a line-level strength control method rather than a single-point adjustment.
V. FAQ: What are the national standards for strength?
Q: What is the national standard requirement for the compressive strength (N) of fertilizer granules?
The national standard is not a single, uniform number, but rather categorized by type and application. Fertilizer-grade potassium chloride ≥25N (GB/T 37918-2019), premium-grade granular ammonium chloride ≥10N (GB/T 2946-2018), and calcium magnesium phosphate ≥15N (GB/T 20412-2021). The group standard for large-particle compound fertilizers requires ≥40N. For ordinary urea granules, a strength greater than 12N/granule is sufficient to meet basic requirements. Controlled-release fertilizers used in mechanical fertilization typically require >40N. The industry generally considers ≥20N as the acceptable reference line, and compound fertilizer companies typically maintain internal controls above 30-50N. The measurement method follows GB/T 44750-2024 “Measurement of Compressive Strength of Granules,” applicable to spherical, cylindrical, and strip-shaped granules with a particle size of 1.0–20.0 mm and a compressive strength of 0.5–10000 N. It’s important to note that strength testing is now a mandatory item in fertilizer quality inspections in many regions. Even if nutrient content is qualified, if strength fails to meet standards, the entire batch may still be deemed unqualified.
If fertilizer granule strength is insufficient, don’t rush to change the formula. Measure and control the granulation moisture content, drying endpoint moisture content, and cooling endpoint temperature one by one. Then, review the compatibility of the binder dosage and the process route. Maintaining these three parameters ensures a stable foundation for granule strength.

